Top 7 Payroll Challenges for Large Saudi Companies — And How Dynamo Payroll Fixes Them

Saudi Arabian businesses face massive penalties when their payroll software fails. Recent fines reached SAR 3 billion in 2024 alone. This is a big deal as it means that compliance-related lawsuits increased by 18% from the previous year. Companies in the GCC reported breaches in their payroll systems, with 15% experiencing recovery costs around SAR 200,000 for the whole ordeal.

The right payroll management software can turn these challenges into opportunities. A 2024 GCC survey reveals how businesses that automated their payroll processes saw 60% fewer processing errors and a 25% boost in employee satisfaction. Companies of all sizes using integrated payroll systems reduced their administrative work by 30% and achieved 20% better data accuracy. Small businesses find these benefits equally valuable – timely and accurate salary payments encourage a positive workplace culture, especially when you have Saudi Arabia’s competitive job market.

Dynamo Payroll provides a detailed solution through its cloud-based HR payroll software built for Microsoft Dynamics 365 Finance and Operations. Our platform helps large Saudi companies overcome their biggest challenges – from staying compliant with changing labor laws to handling complex expatriate payrolls. The following section explores seven critical payroll challenges and shows how Dynamo’s automation, error reduction, and compliance-focused approach tackles each one.

Compliance with Evolving Saudi Labor Laws

Saudi Arabia’s labor regulations keep changing for large companies. The most sweeping reforms since 2015 came in February 2025, and businesses now deal with an increasingly complex regulatory environment. These changes have altered the map of employment contracts and leave entitlements, making life challenging for payroll managers.

What the challenge is

Large Saudi companies must deal with a maze of labor laws that often change without clear guidance for implementation. The 2025 amendments bring major changes that affect employment in many ways:

  • More employer duties toward employees, including rules against discrimination based on gender, age, ethnicity, nationality, marital status, or disability
  • Fresh rules about providing employee accommodation or financial allowances
  • Longer probation periods from 90 to 180 days
  • New structure for fixed-term contracts for non-Saudi employees
  • Different termination rights and notice periods
  • Maternity leave now extends from 10 to 12 weeks
  • Fresh paternity leave benefits

Companies must also stay compliant with the Wage Protection System (WPS), General Organization for Social Insurance (GOSI) contributions, and Saudization quotas under the Nitaqat program. Companies without specialized payroll systems find it almost impossible to track these requirements.

The Ministry of Human Resources and Social Development (MHRSD) now enforces rules more strictly through digital tools like the Qiwa platform. This platform serves as the main hub for employment contract registration, remote work declarations, and Saudization reporting. Digital tracking makes it easier to spot and punish non-compliance.

Why it matters

Non-compliance comes with huge financial risks. Fines for breaking labor laws hit SAR 3 billion in 2024, while compliance-related lawsuits rose 18% from the previous year. On top of that, companies missing Saudization quotas might lose access to government contracts and face blocks on new work visa requests.

Money isn’t the only risk. Non-compliance creates operational problems:

  • Companies can’t renew work permits for non-Saudi employees
  • They face limits on getting new work permits
  • Foreign companies risk blacklisting or losing business licenses
  • Employee complaints and labor disputes with the MHRSD become more likely

Manual payroll processing makes things worse. Human error leads to payroll mistakes in 78% of companies each year. Old payroll systems cut efficiency in 25% of businesses.

Employee trust and company reputation suffer from compliance failures. This can hurt talent acquisition and retention strategies in Saudi Arabia’s competitive job market, especially when violations touch employee pay or benefits.

How Dynamo Payroll solves it

Dynamo Payroll’s cloud-based software for Microsoft Dynamics 365 Finance and Operations tackles these compliance challenges with several key features:

  1. Automated Regulatory Updates: The system tracks changes in Saudi labor laws and automatically updates calculations for wages, overtime, and end-of-service benefits. Payroll stays compliant even as rules change.
  2. Integrated Compliance Monitoring: The software verifies payment data against current regulations in real-time and keeps complete audit trails for labor inspections. It checks all payments against regulatory rules before submission.
  3. Saudization Tracking Tools: Companies can monitor Nitaqat program quotas by sorting employees by nationality and creating instant reports for regulators. This helps avoid costly penalties and keeps access to government services open.
  4. WPS Compliance Features: The software creates properly formatted WPS files automatically, which cuts manual errors and ensures banks accept the format. This makes salary payments through approved channels smoother.
  5. GOSI Contribution Management: The system calculates and tracks social insurance contributions accurately and creates reports needed by both the Ministry of Labor and Social Insurance.

Large Saudi companies benefit from Dynamo Payroll’s speed and accuracy. The automated solutions eliminate calculation errors and reduce processing time by half, which lets HR teams work on strategic projects instead of endless calculations.

The software adapts easily to new employees, different pay structures, and benefits changes as businesses grow in complex regulatory environments. This flexibility helps multinational companies manage diverse workforces in their Saudi operations.

Dynamo Payroll helps large Saudi companies turn compliance from a burden into an advantage. The system’s integrated approach helps businesses remain competitive amid regulatory changes while reducing risk and streamlining processes.

Manual Payroll Processing and Human Error

Saudi companies waste countless hours on manual payroll calculations. Studies show that 70% of payroll errors come from human mistakes. These mistakes cost medium-sized businesses more than SAR 120,000 every year. The problems get worse as companies grow bigger, which creates a chain of issues across operations.

What the challenge is

Manual payroll processing creates several roadblocks for large Saudi companies:

  • Time-intensive operations: Small and medium companies spend about 30 hours each month on manual payroll. This takes HR staff away from more important work.
  • Error-prone calculations: Manual number-crunching leads to mistakes in salaries, overtime, and deductions. This hurts employee trust and job satisfaction.
  • Scalability limitations: Growing businesses don’t deal very well with increased workload using manual systems. This leads to paperwork piling up.
  • Data fragmentation: Employee information scattered across different places raises the risk of mistakes.

Many companies still use spreadsheets and paper documents to process payroll. Staff must type in data by hand to handle calculations, tax filing, and record keeping. HR teams spend too much time on repeat tasks that computers could handle.

Most mistakes happen when calculating overtime, applying tax rates, managing benefit deductions, and tracking attendance. Small errors in these areas can snowball into big payroll problems that affect whole departments.

Why it matters

Manual payroll errors cause problems beyond simple math mistakes:

  1. Financial consequences: Companies lose around SAR 120,000 yearly. They might also face fines when calculation errors lead to compliance issues.
  2. Employee dissatisfaction: Late or wrong payments hurt staff morale and trust. Research shows that “employees may experience financial stress and dissatisfaction, ultimately affecting their performance and loyalty toward the company”.
  3. Reputation damage: Wrong payments hurt a company’s image and finances. This can make more employees quit.
  4. Operational inefficiency: Fixing payroll mistakes wastes time that HR teams could spend on more important work.
  5. Legal vulnerability: Saudi Arabia’s strict business rules mean manual errors can lead to legal troubles.

These problems get worse over time. Each mistake makes employees trust the company less, creates more work to fix errors, and might cause compliance issues that only show up during audits.

How Dynamo Payroll solves it

Dynamo Payroll offers a complete solution to fix these manual processing headaches:

Automated calculation engine: The system wipes out calculation errors by automating everything – salaries, overtime, and deductions – all following Saudi labor laws. The software applies exact rules while factoring in job conditions, tax rates, and benefits.

Time savings: Companies cut their processing time by more than 50% by automating repeat tasks. This lets HR teams focus on strategy instead of paperwork.

Microsoft integration: Dynamo Payroll merges naturally with Microsoft Dynamics 365 Finance and Operations. This stops data from getting scattered and cuts down on entry errors.

Built-in validation: The system checks for errors at many points before processing. This layered checking almost completely stops common payroll mistakes.

Scalability: The system grows with your business. You won’t need to hire more admin staff just because your workforce gets bigger.

Implementation efficiency: While other big systems take months to set up, you can start using Dynamo in less than 8 weeks. This means you see returns on your investment quickly.

Dynamo Payroll turns a risky manual task into a smooth, accurate process. Large Saudi companies with complex payroll needs – different employee types, various allowances, multiple tax structures – see immediate improvements in their operations.

Taking human error out of the equation helps businesses stay accurate and gives HR teams time to work on things that really matter for company success.

Lack of Integration Between HR, Finance, and Payroll Systems

Saudi Arabia’s corporate landscape faces a major roadblock – disconnected systems that hinder efficient payroll management. Big companies often struggle as their HR, finance, and payroll platforms don’t work together. This creates information bottlenecks and puts compliance at risk.

What the challenge is

System fragmentation creates the biggest hurdle for essential business operations. Teams from HR, finance, and accounting can’t sync their data properly, which leads to operational problems. Companies without proper integration face several issues:

  • Data bottlenecks slow down critical processes and create information silos
  • Manual transfer of information between systems increases error risks
  • Inconsistent data sharing between departments gets pricey with mistakes
  • Technical malfunctions hurt compliance with wage protection programs
  • Delayed employee payments happen due to failed integration with financial institutions

Large Saudi organizations deal with constant data reconciliation headaches. Their HR team might update employee information in one system while finance handles payroll in another. This creates mismatches they must fix manually every pay cycle.

The fragmented payroll software market makes everything harder. Many vendors offer different systems that don’t work together. Businesses struggle to connect their payroll, compensation management, HR, and finance systems.

Free Zone establishments add another layer of complexity to the region. These zones work under different regulatory frameworks, with their own visa and employment policies. This makes integration even more difficult.

Why it matters

Poor system integration causes problems that go way beyond simple inconvenience. Organizations without good connections between HR and payroll systems face:

Financial Impact: Bad data management can cost millions, especially in finance industries where accuracy matters most. Companies that invest in integration without strategy face heavy delays and surprise costs.

Compliance Failures: Problems with partner financial institutions and technical issues hurt compliance with the Wage Protection System. This can lead to penalties from authorities. SAMA stresses fixing these technical issues so establishments can pay wages on time.

Operational Inefficiency: Companies stuck with manual processes find them “too slow, too consuming and full of mistakes”. These errors hurt both company finances and team morale.

Data Accuracy Problems: Isolated HR, finance, and payroll operations make it impossible to keep employee data consistent. This affects simple payroll calculations and strategic workforce planning.

Implementation Challenges: System integration offers great benefits but isn’t simple. Many organizations find their new systems clash with older legacy software, making efficiency harder to achieve.

How Dynamo Payroll solves it

Dynamo Payroll gives large Saudi companies a complete solution to their integration challenges:

Complete System Integration: Built within Microsoft Dynamics 365 Finance and Operations, Dynamo Payroll removes data silos. It works in the same environment as your financial and operational systems, letting data flow smoothly between HR, finance, and payroll.

Unified Data Environment: Dynamo gives you “the power of one seamless global system for all your workforce management needs”. You get complete clarity and live updates across your workforce. This unified approach eliminates inconsistencies found in disconnected systems.

Automated Workflows: The system creates integrated workflows that connect with payroll actions. It can automatically calculate end-of-service benefits when visas get canceled. These automated processes keep data consistent and reduce manual work.

Strategic Decision Support: Dynamo helps administrative staff become knowledge workers. It enables HR departments to play vital strategic roles in organizational success. The core team gets instant access to insights through custom reports and dashboards.

Compliance Assurance: System integration helps ensure compliance with all-in-one software. Dynamo makes reporting, reconciliation, data management, and document generation simple while maintaining compliance across key processes.

Simplified Implementation: Unlike complex integration projects that take months, Dynamo cuts down implementation time, cost, and effort. Companies can see integration benefits without long operational disruptions.

Improved Employee Experience: The system boosts staff involvement through self-service features. Team members can access their information without overwhelming HR staff with routine requests.

Dynamo Payroll helps large Saudi companies turn their disconnected systems into smooth, efficient payroll operations. Companies juggling complex requirements across different employee categories and regulations see more than just fewer errors and better compliance. They fundamentally improve how they manage their most valuable asset—their people.

Managing End-of-Service Benefits (EOSB) Accurately

EOSB is a vital financial obligation for employers across Saudi Arabia. Many large organizations find it challenging to calculate these benefits accurately. This severance-like payout provides employees with a financial safety net that is different from Western pension models.

What the challenge is

Saudi companies face several complexities when calculating EOSB. The formula changes based on multiple variables:

  • Service duration differentiation: Half-month salary for each of the first five years, followed by one full month’s salary for each subsequent year
  • Termination circumstances: Different calculations apply depending on whether employment ends through resignation, contract expiry, termination with cause, or termination without cause
  • Contract type implications: Limited-term versus unlimited-term contracts follow different calculation methods
  • Employee classification: Special provisions exist for specific employee categories, such as women who terminate contracts within six months of marriage or three months after childbirth

Large companies still rely on manual calculations for these benefits, which creates room for error. Saudi Arabia’s regulatory landscape continues to evolve, and payroll departments must stay alert to regular amendments.

Miscalculations happen frequently because payroll teams need to think over variables beyond simple tenure. These include unused leave balances, final salary determinations, and proper application of termination rules. Organizations without specialized systems become vulnerable to calculation errors and regulatory non-compliance.

Why it matters

EOSB errors bring substantial financial and reputational consequences. Employers who underpay EOSB risk legal action from employees who can report violations to the Saudi Ministry of Human Resources and Social Development. Overpayments directly hurt financial performance through unnecessary expense.

Mismanaged EOSB calculations damage employee trust. Saudi Labor Law guarantees these benefits as a fundamental right, and accurate payments demonstrate an employer’s steadfast dedication to fair treatment. Calculation errors harm this trust and can affect current workforce morale and future recruitment efforts.

Financial implications grow as companies expand. Small calculation errors can multiply into material financial misstatements for organizations with hundreds or thousands of employees. Finance departments must manually provision for future liabilities without proper systems, which creates potential accounting inconsistencies.

EOSB management plays a key role in workforce planning. Organizations that track and project these benefits can forecast future financial obligations better. Companies lacking visibility into upcoming expenses often face unexpected financial burdens during restructuring or downsizing.

How Dynamo Payroll solves it

Dynamo Payroll streamlines these challenges through complete automation designed for Saudi labor regulations. The system delivers automated EOSB calculations that match specific legal requirements for each employment category. This precision ensures compliance and helps HR and payroll teams work more efficiently.

The software keeps detailed records of employee service durations, salary histories, and relevant employment status changes – key elements for accurate EOSB computation. Dynamo eliminates calculation errors by centralizing this information.

Dynamo Payroll gives employees transparent EOSB statements that promote trust through clear documentation of entitlements. This transparency prevents disputes by helping all parties understand the calculation process.

Microsoft Dynamics 365 Finance and Operations integration lets finance departments properly account for these liabilities while maintaining accurate financial records. Dynamo updates calculation formulas automatically whenever Saudi labor laws change. This ongoing compliance protects organizations from regulatory penalties whatever the frequency of legislative changes.

Dynamo’s Employee Master Index stores historical records of all employee information and creates a complete audit trail. This historical tracking becomes invaluable during labor inspections or employee disputes.

Dynamo revolutionizes EOSB management from a complex liability into a streamlined, compliant process. The system eliminates calculation errors and provides documentation that protects large Saudi companies from financial and regulatory risks.

Multi-Currency and Expat Payroll Complexities

Large companies face unique payroll challenges when managing expatriate employees in Saudi Arabia. The GCC region employs a huge international workforce, which requires companies to handle multiple currencies, different benefits structures, and complex compliance requirements at once.

What the challenge is

Saudi businesses encounter several challenges in expatriate payroll:

  • Complex compensation structures: Companies must handle different visa statuses, benefits, housing allowances, and sometimes dual currencies (local currency for salary and USD for bonuses)
  • Currency fluctuation risks: Exchange rate changes directly affect payroll costs and can lead to wrong employee compensation
  • Compliance across jurisdictions: Expatriate payroll requires tax compliance in multiple jurisdictions and strict adherence to immigration laws
  • Inconsistent payment delivery: Banking systems vary greatly, making timely payments difficult for employees from different countries

Saudi organizations with international employees often see uneven salary payments. Their staff might receive different amounts each month because of exchange rate changes. This inconsistency creates financial and administrative problems.

Why it matters

Wrong handling of multi-currency payroll leads to serious problems:

Employee satisfaction and motivation drop sharply when salary payments are inconsistent. Staff members who receive less than expected become frustrated, which often increases turnover rates. Companies that fail to pay correctly might breach employment contracts.

Sudden currency exchange changes can make payroll costs unmanageable. Companies with employees in countries with unstable currencies often exceed their financial budgets and drain resources.

Businesses must know the regulations for each employee’s country, including minimum wage rules, healthcare taxes, and local compliance requirements. Companies face penalties, lawsuits, or operational shutdowns if they don’t follow these rules properly.

How Dynamo Payroll solves it

Dynamo Payroll offers specialized features for Saudi Arabia’s international workforce:

Multi-currency processing: The system handles multiple currencies through easy-to-use support that meets global business needs. Employers and employees stay protected against major currency changes while receiving payments on time.

Flexible payroll structures: The platform creates adaptable structures with custom allowance categories—housing, transport, relocation, education—based on nationality, seniority, or company policies.

Real-time exchange rate integration: Automatic exchange rate updates ensure accurate salary conversions and compliance in multi-currency processing.

Expatriate-specific configurations: The system calculates contributions correctly for expatriates who have different requirements (only 2% employer contribution for occupational hazards with no employee contribution to GOSI).

Streamlined compliance management: Complex regulatory requirements across multiple jurisdictions become simpler, which reduces the work for internal teams.

Dynamo Payroll, part of Microsoft Dynamics 365 Finance and Operations, turns multi-currency and expatriate payroll into an efficient, compliant process. Saudi companies with diverse international workforces can now work more efficiently, keep employees happy, and avoid financial and regulatory risks.

Ensuring WPS Compliance and Timely Salary Disbursement

Saudi Arabian companies find it hard to deal with the Wage Protection System (WPS), which is a strict electronic monitoring framework. This system aims to protect worker rights but creates major operational challenges for payroll departments throughout the Kingdom.

What the challenge is

Companies must submit their monthly payroll data electronically through the Mudad portal. The process requires them to upload specific file formats to banking systems. Organizations need to:

  • Pay salaries through WPS-approved methods by the 10th of every month
  • Ensure payroll files match exact electronic specifications required by government systems
  • Document all exceptions (unpaid employees) with specific justifications
  • Keep clear communication channels between HR and payroll departments

Most companies don’t have the right systems to create these specialized files automatically. They rely on manual processes that often lead to errors and fail to meet compliance standards.

Why it matters

Saudi businesses face tough penalties when they don’t comply with WPS regulations. They can be fined up to SAR 5,000 per employee for late or missing reports. The problems don’t stop there. Non-compliant organizations also face:

  • Labor office service suspension
  • Work permit renewal restrictions
  • Limited ability to process new work visas
  • Higher employee dissatisfaction and turnover

These issues can bring business operations to a halt. WPS compliance has become crucial for large Saudi companies to survive.

How Dynamo Payroll solves it

Dynamo Payroll makes WPS compliance simple and straightforward through its specialized features:

Automated WPS file generation – The system creates properly formatted files for the Mudad portal automatically. This removes formatting errors that often happen with manual preparation.

Bank integration – Dynamo connects directly with financial institutions. This ensures salaries are transferred on time and meet WPS requirements.

Exception management – Users can document and track justified exceptions easily. The system keeps detailed records ready for regulatory checks.

Compliance monitoring – Built-in checks verify WPS compliance before submission. This prevents violations that could result in penalties.

Dynamo works as a cloud-based payroll software specifically built for Microsoft Dynamics 365 Finance and Operations. It gives companies the tools they need to handle Saudi Arabia’s strict WPS requirements with confidence.

Data Security and Local Data Residency Requirements

Saudi Arabia’s evolving data protection framework creates new challenges for companies that manage sensitive payroll information. Companies must prepare for the Personal Data Protection Law (PDPL) taking full effect in September 2024. This law enforces strict rules for handling employee data.

What the challenge is

Large Saudi companies need to direct their way through complex data residency rules about storing payroll information. Saudi’s PDPL requires specific data types to stay within its borders. The law strictly controls cross-border data transfers. Payroll operations face extra strict requirements:

  • Government entity data stays in Saudi Arabia unless there’s explicit permission
  • Saudi’s Income Tax Law requires taxpayer records to stay within the Kingdom
  • Labor Law demands that labor records stay at the workplace

Companies must also build strong security measures to protect sensitive payroll data from breaches. These measures need encryption for stored and moving data, role-based access controls, and detailed audit trails.

Why it matters

Breaking data residency rules leads to harsh penalties. Moving data across borders illegally can put you in prison for up to one year. You might also face fines up to 1 million Saudi riyal (about 250,000 Euro). The damage goes beyond just money:

Companies might lose their access to key government services. This makes it hard to process visas or run normal business operations. Data breaches hurt both finances and reputation badly. Each incident costs around SAR 200,000 to fix. Companies without proper systems find it hard to prove they follow rules during audits.

How Dynamo Payroll solves it

Dynamo Payroll takes a detailed approach to keep data secure and follow residency rules. Their system offers secure deployment options with local hosting that meets Saudi Arabia’s strict data rules.

Microsoft Dynamics 365 Finance and Operations powers Dynamo’s multi-layered security. The system encrypts stored and moving data. It limits data access to essential staff only and keeps detailed records of all system activities.

Dynamo stays current with changing regulations through regular updates that match Saudi Arabia’s data protection framework. The platform’s security follows industry best practices. These include strong authentication methods, minimal access controls, and constant monitoring.

Large Saudi companies can turn data security from a regulatory headache into a business advantage with Dynamo Payroll. The platform helps minimize compliance risks while making operations more efficient.

Conclusion

Transforming Payroll Challenges into Strategic Advantages

Large Saudi companies face many payroll challenges that lead to hefty financial penalties, compliance issues, and operational inefficiencies. These challenges might seem daunting, but Dynamo Payroll turns potential problems into strategic advantages with its detailed solutions.

Success comes from tackling each challenge step by step. Dynamo Payroll handles compliance with Saudi labor laws through automated updates that keep up with new legislation. The system’s automated calculation engine eliminates human errors and cuts processing time by more than 50%.

The system works naturally with Microsoft Dynamics 365 Finance and Operations. This creates a unified environment where HR, finance, and payroll data move freely. The integration helps with complex calculations like End-of-Service Benefits, which the system processes automatically based on legal requirements for each type of employment.

Dynamo’s multi-currency processing and flexible structures make expatriate payroll simple. WPS compliance becomes straightforward with automated file generation and direct bank integration. Companies don’t need to worry about data security thanks to secure deployment models with in-country hosting that meets Saudi Arabia’s strict data rules.

The cloud-based system delivers these benefits while letting employees help themselves, which reduces administrative work. Companies using this solution see impressive results – 60% fewer processing errors, 25% happier employees, 30% less administrative work, and 20% better data accuracy.

We’ve watched Dynamo Payroll help large Saudi companies handle complex rules while working more efficiently. Companies feel secure knowing the system focuses on reducing errors, automation, and following regulations in Saudi Arabia’s demanding payroll environment.

Business leaders should ask themselves: Can we risk non-compliance penalties, expensive mistakes, and slow processes? Dynamo Payroll shows a clear way forward – turning payroll from a burden into an asset that helps businesses grow while protecting them from regulatory risks.

Saudi Arabia’s payroll world changes quickly. Companies with Dynamo Payroll stay ahead of these changes and manage their workforce duties with confidence while focusing on their main business goals.

FAQs

Q1. What are the main payroll challenges for large companies in Saudi Arabia?

Large Saudi companies face several key payroll challenges, including compliance with evolving labor laws, manual processing errors, lack of system integration, complex end-of-service benefit calculations, managing expatriate payrolls, ensuring Wage Protection System (WPS) compliance, and meeting data security requirements.

Q2. How often must salaries be paid in Saudi Arabia?

According to Saudi labor laws, salaries must be paid either weekly or monthly. Employees on a weekly payroll must be compensated at least once per week, while those on a monthly payroll must receive their wages at least once per month.

Q3. Is a 13th-month salary mandatory in Saudi Arabia?

No, 13th-month payments are not mandatory in Saudi Arabia. However, employers have the discretion to offer performance-based bonuses or other additional payments if they choose to do so.

Q4. What are the consequences of non-compliance with payroll regulations in Saudi Arabia?

Non-compliance can result in severe penalties, including fines of up to SAR 5,000 per employee for late or missing reports, suspension of labor office services, restrictions on work permit renewals, and limitations on processing new work visas. These consequences can significantly disrupt business operations.

Q5. How can automated payroll systems benefit large Saudi companies?

Automated payroll systems like Dynamo Payroll can provide numerous benefits, including a 60% reduction in processing errors, 25% improvement in employee satisfaction, 30% reduction in administrative workload, and 20% better data accuracy. They also ensure compliance with evolving regulations, streamline complex calculations, and enhance data security.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *